Picture two retirees who each start with $1,000,000 and follow the same spending plan, except that one portfolio earns 6% a year and the other earns 4%. Ten years later, the first has about $260,000 more, even though both withdrew exactly the same dollars. That gap is why many retirement models split the pre-retirement vs. post-retirement rate of return instead of using one number for your whole life.
Quick Answer: A pre-retirement rate of return is the growth rate assumed while you're still contributing (the accumulation phase). A post-retirement rate of return applies while you're withdrawing (the withdrawal phase). Many calculators set the second one lower to reflect a more conservative portfolio, but once withdrawals begin, the order of returns matters too.
Why the Pre-Retirement vs. Post-Retirement Rate of Return Plays a Different Role
Before retirement, a portfolio is mostly receiving money. You contribute through a 401(k), an IRA, or a taxable account, and the balance grows from both new deposits and investment returns. A bad year hurts, but fresh contributions keep arriving, and they buy investments at lower prices.
After retirement, the cash flow reverses. Contributions usually stop, and you start selling investments to cover living expenses while the rest of the portfolio stays invested. Every withdrawal permanently removes dollars that can no longer take part in a later recovery.
| Accumulation phase | Withdrawal phase | |
|---|---|---|
| Main cash flow | Contributions in | Withdrawals out |
| What drives the balance | Contributions + growth | Growth − withdrawals |
| Effect of a market decline | New contributions buy at lower prices | Withdrawals may require selling at lower prices |
| Typical question | "How much could I have saved?" | "How long could this money last?" |
Because the money moves in opposite directions, the same return assumption does different work in each phase. A single blended rate can make a plan look smoother than it really is. If you haven't settled on a growth figure for your saving years yet, start with our guide to what return rate to assume for retirement planning, then come back to what changes once withdrawals begin.
When a Lower Post-Retirement Return Assumption Makes Sense
The main argument for a lower post-retirement return is about asset allocation. Many investors reduce stocks and add bonds or cash as retirement approaches. Fidelity describes the trade-off: more stocks can raise a portfolio's return potential, but they also bring larger short-term losses. If your mix becomes more conservative, a model that keeps your accumulation-phase return may overstate what the portfolio is likely to earn.
The investment horizon shifts too. A 35-year-old has decades before touching the money. A 67-year-old retiree may need to sell investments this year, next year, and every year after, which can change how much short-term volatility they're willing or able to take.
Several popular calculators build this in by default. NerdWallet's retirement calculator assumes a 6% return before retirement and 5% during retirement, citing a more conservative portfolio. SmartAsset's retirement calculator also uses different return assumptions and a lower stock allocation during retirement.
A lower rate is a modeling convention, though, not a law of finance. A retirement can last 25 to 30 years or longer, and some retirees keep a substantial stock allocation so their savings can keep pace with inflation. For them, the same rate in both phases may be a reasonable scenario, as long as it's also tested against weaker outcomes. In every case, a 5% post-retirement input doesn't mean the portfolio will earn 5% in any given year, or even on average. It's a planning input that makes scenarios comparable.
How Much a Two-Point Difference in Retirement Returns Costs
To isolate the effect of the post-retirement rate, here is one hypothetical retiree with a single input changed.
Assumptions (hypothetical): $1,000,000 starting portfolio; first withdrawal of $40,000 at the end of year 1, rising 3% a year to roughly track living costs; constant return of 4% in one scenario and 6% in the other; the balance earns that year's return first, then the withdrawal comes out at year-end; no taxes, fees, or other income.
| Year | Withdrawal (end of year) | Balance at 4% | Balance at 6% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $40,000.00 | $1,000,000.00 | $1,020,000.00 |
| 2 | $41,200.00 | $998,800.00 | $1,040,000.00 |
| 3 | $42,436.00 | $996,316.00 | $1,059,964.00 |
| 4 | $43,709.08 | $992,459.56 | $1,079,852.76 |
| 5 | $45,020.35 | $987,137.59 | $1,099,623.57 |
| 6 | $46,370.96 | $980,252.13 | $1,119,230.02 |
| 7 | $47,762.09 | $971,700.12 | $1,138,621.73 |
| 8 | $49,194.95 | $961,373.17 | $1,157,744.08 |
| 9 | $50,670.80 | $949,157.30 | $1,176,537.93 |
| 10 | $52,190.93 | $934,932.66 | $1,194,939.27 |
Calculated without intermediate rounding; shown to the nearest cent.
Both scenarios withdraw the same $458,555 over ten years. After year 10, the 6% portfolio holds $260,007 more than the 4% portfolio, a gap worth more than a quarter of the starting balance.
The direction of travel matters as much as the gap. At 4%, the first year's earnings exactly cover the first withdrawal, but from year 2 the rising withdrawals outpace earnings and the balance starts drifting down. At 6%, earnings stay ahead of withdrawals for the whole decade, so the balance keeps climbing. Over a longer retirement, the gap would likely keep widening.
None of this makes 6% the "right" number or 4% a "safe" one. Both are constant rates, and real portfolios don't earn the same return every year.
Why the Order of Returns Matters Once Withdrawals Begin
With no money flowing in or out, the order of returns doesn't change the ending balance: a 20% loss followed by a 25% gain lands in the same place as the reverse. Once withdrawals start, that symmetry breaks. This is sequence-of-returns risk, and Fidelity flags the early years of retirement as the period when investors may be most exposed to it.
Assumptions (hypothetical): $1,000,000 starting portfolio; a flat $40,000 withdrawal at the end of each year; returns of −20% and +25% in either order; no taxes or fees.
| Year 1 return | End of year 1 (after withdrawal) | Year 2 return | End of year 2 (after withdrawal) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Path A: loss first | −20% | $760,000 | +25% | $910,000 |
| Path B: gain first | +25% | $1,210,000 | −20% | $928,000 |
Same returns, same withdrawals, yet Path B ends $18,000 ahead. Without withdrawals, both paths would finish at exactly $1,000,000.
The reason is what each withdrawal costs. In Path A, the first $40,000 comes out of a portfolio that has already shrunk to $800,000, so it's 5% of the balance, and those dollars miss the 25% rebound. In Path B, the same $40,000 is only 3.2% of a $1,250,000 balance and is already out before the decline.
Over two years the gap is modest. Over a 25- or 30-year retirement, a deep decline in the first few years can leave meaningfully fewer assets to recover, even if long-term average returns turn out fine. That's why average return alone can't tell you whether a withdrawal plan will hold up.
Hidden Drags: Inflation, Fees, and Taxes
Return assumptions in most projections are nominal, so inflation hits a retiree twice. Withdrawals tend to rise with prices, which is why Example 1 raised them by 3% a year, while the portfolio's real return sits below its nominal return. At 3% inflation, a 6% nominal return is roughly 2.9% in real terms, and 4% nominal is roughly 1%. We walk through the formulas in how inflation affects retirement savings.
Fees quietly lower the return you actually keep. The SEC's investor education office shows a hypothetical $100,000 earning 4% a year for 20 years: with a 0.25% annual fee it grows to about $208,000, and with a 0.50% fee to about $198,000. In retirement, the same drag hits a portfolio that is also funding withdrawals. If 1% in annual costs turned Example 1's 6% gross return into about 5% net, the year-10 balance would fall from $1,194,939 to about $1,058,938, with the same withdrawals.
Taxes work the same way. Withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts such as a traditional 401(k) or IRA are generally taxable, so covering $40,000 of spending may take a larger gross withdrawal. Neither example here models taxes.
How to Stress-Test Your Return Assumptions for Each Phase
Treat "How much could I accumulate?" and "How long could it last?" as separate questions, each with its own assumption tied to the portfolio you expect to hold in that phase. If you plan to de-risk at retirement, test a lower post-retirement rate. If you'll keep a similar mix, the same rate is a fair scenario, but run a lower one beside it.
Run at least two constant rates per phase and keep the limits in mind. A fixed-rate projection draws a smooth line, and real markets don't. It's useful for comparing assumptions, but it can't show how an early downturn combined with withdrawals might shorten how long the money lasts.
Withdrawal research is built the same way, on explicit assumptions. Morningstar's 2025 State of Retirement Income report put the starting safe withdrawal rate for new retirees at 3.9%, up from 3.7% the year before. That figure assumes fixed inflation-adjusted withdrawals, a 30-year horizon, a 90% probability of money remaining, a portfolio with roughly 30% to 50% in equities, and forward-looking rather than historical return estimates. Change any one of those and the number moves, which is a useful reminder that no projection is a guarantee.
To set your accumulation results against what you'll actually spend, see how much you need to retire, or browse the full Retirement Planning hub.
Test Your Pre-Retirement Return Assumptions
👉 Open the retirement savings calculator
Use it before you commit to a single growth number. It projects your balance at retirement from your current age, retirement age, current savings, monthly contribution, and expected annual return. It shows the result in both nominal dollars and today's purchasing power, and it puts 5%, 6.5%, and 8% scenarios side by side, which is a quick way to see how sensitive your nest egg is to the pre-retirement assumption.
It covers the accumulation phase only. It doesn't simulate withdrawals, sequence-of-returns risk, variable year-to-year returns, or the odds of running out of money; its projection stops at your retirement age. The withdrawal examples above are separate, simplified illustrations.
Related calculators:
- Compound interest calculator: see how a single return assumption compounds over time
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I use a lower rate of return after retirement?
It's worth testing one, but it isn't a universal rule. A lower post-retirement rate fits best if your portfolio will actually shift toward bonds and cash. If your mix will stay similar, a lower rate still works as a cautious second scenario. The right input depends on your asset allocation, costs, and time horizon. A qualified financial professional can help you apply it to your situation.
How much lower should the post-retirement rate be?
There's no standard gap. Calculator defaults often sit about one to two percentage points below the pre-retirement rate (NerdWallet's 6% and 5% is one example), but those defaults reflect a generic portfolio, not yours. A more useful approach is to estimate the return of the mix you expect to hold in retirement, subtract your expected fees, and test a scenario below that.
Should return assumptions be nominal or real?
Either works, but don't mix them. If you enter a nominal return (say 6%), inflation has to be handled separately, by raising withdrawals each year or converting the result into today's dollars. If you enter a real return (say about 3%), inflation is already built in, and adjusting for it again would double-count it and understate your outcome.
Is a 4% withdrawal rate the same as a 4% investment return?
No. A withdrawal rate is how much you take out, usually as a share of the starting balance in year one. An investment return is how much the portfolio earns. In Example 1, the first withdrawal is 4% of the portfolio and the return is also 4%, yet the balance still declines because withdrawals rise 3% a year. Withdrawal-rate research such as Morningstar's models variable returns over decades rather than assuming the portfolio earns its withdrawal rate every year.
Key Takeaways
Pre-retirement returns describe growth while you contribute; post-retirement returns describe growth while you withdraw.
A lower post-retirement rate usually reflects a more conservative portfolio, but it's a modeling choice, not a forecast.
In a hypothetical 10-year example with identical withdrawals, 6% left about $260,000 more than 4%.
Once withdrawals begin, the order of returns matters alongside their average, because selling during a decline can lock in losses.
A withdrawal rate is not an investment return; confusing the two can make a plan look sturdier than it is.
The retirement savings calculator models the accumulation phase only, not withdrawals, sequence risk, or the probability of running out of money.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Please consult a qualified financial advisor before making relevant decisions.
